French Pronouns: En vs. Y
French pronoun “en” and “y” are 2 very useful and multifunctional pronouns. Erase any confusions with this article. Learn French with Talk in French
Confused about French pronouns en and y?
Don’t worry, French grammar may not be simple but it is indeed very logical and detail-oriented. In this article, let’s try to remove once and for all any confusion you might still have over the French pronouns en and y.
You have probably seen them many many times already when reading French text. But when to use them, which types of nouns can they replace? Just take 5 minutes to go through this article and you won’t need to ask these anymore.
What exactly are en and y?
‘Y’ and ‘en’ are minuscule French pronouns, yeah, so minuscule that some think they can be removed from the sentence.
However, ‘y’ and ‘en’ are so powerful in the construction of French sentences for these two can change the entire sense of the sentence and sometimes the whole paragraph. Just like how bacteria can change the world if they are omitted.
So if you think your French sentences still don’t make sense after you have read and applied all the things that you have learned from all the French articles here in this website, this might help you a lot.
Let’s learn more about the pronouns y and en in French!
Y: Replaces Something but not Someone
You were probably taught that the English counterpart of ‘y’ is ‘there.’ Well, yeah, that’s the most popular or the easiest way to use ‘y’ but actually, it’s just one of its many uses.
Y commonly replaces à + a thing or idea. It also replaces a place introduced by a preposition such as à, dans, en, or chez: Je vais chez Paul → J’y vais (I am going to Paul’s place → I am going there).
Some of you might say “But that is the structure to be replaced by an indirect object pronoun“. Yes, actually it looks very similar, but there is a difference.
As a learner’s rule, use y for things, ideas, or places, rather than people. For a person, use the pronoun required by the verb: Je pense à Marie → Je pense à elle, but Je parle à Marie → Je lui parle. Some expressions and familiar uses allow y to refer to a person, so “never a person” is not an absolute rule.
Example:
- Nous allons à Paris demainWe are going to Paris tomorrow
- Nous y allons demain.We are going there tomorrow
- Nous pensons à la situationWe are thinking about the situation
- Nous y pensonsWe are thinking about it
EN: De + Noun
En often corresponds to “of it,” “of them,” “about it,” or “some,” depending on the construction. English may leave this meaning implicit; French uses en when it is needed to replace the relevant complement.
En replaces the structure partitive article + noun or de + noun.
- As-tu du pain ?Do you have any bread?
- Oui, j’en aiYes, I have (some of it).
- As-tu besoin d’aide?Do you need help?
- Oui, j’en ai besoin.Yes, I need some.
With a number, en replaces the noun and the number stays in the sentence. It often follows the verb, but other words can follow it: J’en ai acheté cinq hier (I bought five of them yesterday).
En also replaces a noun introduced by a quantity expression, such as beaucoup or la moitié. Keep the quantity expression; it does not have to be the final word in the sentence.
